Ley orgánica de regulación de la eutanasia: conocimiento e implicación de los médicos en España tras un año de su aplicación / Organic Law Regulating Euthanasia: Knowledge and involvement of doctors in Spain one year after its implementation

Antecedentes y objetivo En junio de 2021 se produjo la entrada en vigor de la ley orgánica reguladora de la eutanasia (LORE). Este estudio tiene como objetivo analizar el conocimiento, implicación y repercusión de la LORE por parte de los médicos colegiados en España. Métodos Estudio descriptivo y con un diseño transversal mediante encuesta. La información se recogió mediante un cuestionario autoadministrado. ResultadosLa encuesta fue respondida por 1.446 médicos colegiados en España. Características demográficas de la muestra: 54,7% eran mujeres, la edad media de los facultativos fue de 52±14, 66% trabajaba en un hospital y la comunidad autónoma con mayor número de participantes fue Cataluña con 44,6%. Por especialidades, anestesiología y reanimación, con 21,9%, fue la especialidad con mayor número de participantes, seguida por medicina familiar y comunitaria (18,5%). De los médicos, 24,3% afirmó conocer la LORE en detalle, 58% tenían una opinión favorable, y 31,1% habían tenido alguna experiencia cercana con el procedimiento eutanásico. Los facultativos que trabajaban dentro del ámbito hospitalario percibieron la ley de forma más favorable en comparación con los de medicina primaria (62,3 vs. 47,3%, p<0,01). Conclusione La gran mayoría de médicos no conocían la LORE, aunque estaban a favor de su existencia, sobre todo los de medicina hospitalaria. Aquellos con mayor percepción negativa de la LORE eran varones, de edad más avanzada y trabajadores de atención primaria. Una minoría se planteaba ser objetor de conciencia (A)

Background and aims The Organic Law Regulating Euthanasia (LORE, for its initials in Spanish) came into force in June 2021. This study aims to examine knowledge of the LORE among physicians licensed in Spain as well as their involvement with and the impact of the law. Methods This work is a descriptive, cross-sectional study conducted by means of a survey. Information was gathered through a self-administered questionnaire. Results The survey was answered by 1446 physicians licensed in Spain. The sample's demographic characteristics were as follows: 54.7% were women, the mean age was 52±14 years, and 66.0% worked in a hospital. Catalonia was the autonomous community with the most participants (44.6%). Regarding specialties, anesthesiology and resuscitation had the highest number of participants (21.9%), followed by family and community medicine (18.5%). The LORE was known in detail by 24.3% of physicians, 58.0% had a positive opinion of it, and 31.1% had direct experience with the euthanasia procedure. Practitioners working in the hospital setting perceived the law more favorably compared to those in the primary care setting (62.3% vs. 47.3%, p<0.01). Conclusions Most doctors did not have in-depth knowledge of the LORE, although a majority supported its existence, particularly those in hospital medicine. Most physicians who viewed the LORE negatively were male, older, and worked in primary care. A minority of physicians considered registering as conscientious objectors (AU)

Organic law regulating euthanasia: knowledge and involvement of doctors in Spain one year after its implementation.

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: The Organic Law Regulating Euthanasia (LORE, for its initials in Spanish) came into force in June 2021. This study aims to examine knowledge of the LORE among physicians licensed in Spain as well as their involvement with and the impact of the law. METHODS: This work is a descriptive, cross-sectional study conducted by means of a survey. Information was gathered through a self-administered questionnaire. RESULTS: The survey was answered by 1446 physicians licensed in Spain. The samples' demographic characteristics were as follows: 54.7% were women, the mean age was 52 ±â€¯14 years, and 66.0% worked in a hospital. Catalonia was the autonomous community with the most participants (44.6%). Regarding specialties, anesthesiology and resuscitation had the highest number of participants (21.9%), followed by family and community medicine (18.5%). The LORE was known in detail by 24.3% of physicians, 58.0% had a positive opinion of it, and 31.1% had direct experience with the euthanasia procedure. Practitioners working in the hospital setting perceived the law more favorably compared to those in the primary care setting (62.3% vs. 47.3%, p < 0.01). CONCLUSIONS: Most doctors did not have in-depth knowledge of the LORE, although a majority supported its existence, particularly those in hospital medicine. Most physicians who viewed the LORE negatively were male, older, and worked in primary care. A minority of physicians considered registering as conscientious objectors.

Intensive Care Unit Approach to the Diagnosis of Brain Death in Infratentorial Neurologic Pathology: Case Reports.

The ischemic and primary vascular injury of the brainstem (BS) can determine, among other serious conditions, the brain death (BD) of the individual. We present 2 cases of individuals with primary ischemic vascular disease of the BS who evolved to BD and were donors of solid organs and tissues. In both cases, the clinical examination was positive for the diagnosis of BD, and transcranial Doppler did not confirm the pattern of cerebral circulatory arrest that accompanies BD. The magnetic resonance angiography performed on 1 patient confirmed the lesion etiology and the presence of vascular obstruction. Both patients were real and effective organ and tissue donors. In these cases, we suggest not to resort to transcranial Doppler as an auxiliary diagnostic test.

Practical document on the management of hyponatremia in critically ill patients. / Documento práctico del manejo de la hiponatremia en pacientes críticos.

Hyponatremia is the most prevalent electrolyte disorder in Intensive Care Units. It is associated with an increase in morbidity, mortality and hospital stay. The majority of the published studies are observational, retrospective and do not include critical patients; hence it is difficult to draw definitive conclusions. Moreover, the lack of clinical evidence has led to important dissimilarities in the recommendations coming from different scientific societies. Finally, etiopathogenic mechanisms leading to hyponatremia in the critical care patient are complex and often combined, and an intensive analysis is clearly needed. A study was therefore made to review all clinical aspects about hyponatremia management in the critical care setting. The aim was to develop a Spanish nationwide algorithm to standardize hyponatremia diagnosis and treatment in the critical care patient.

Effects of medetomidine and medetomidine-butorphanol on transcranial color-coded duplex ultrasonography in healthy dogs.

The study was designed to determine the effects of two protocols of sedation, medetomidine and medetomidine-butorphanol, on cerebral blood flow (CBF) by transcranial color-coded Duplex ultrasonography in healthy dogs. Transcranial Doppler ultrasonographic examination was performed in 20 dogs before and 20 min after sedation with either medetomidine (group 1) or medetomidine-butorphanol (group 2). The left and right middle cerebral arteries (LMCA and RMCA) were evaluated using the temporal windows, and the basilar artery (BA) was studied through the suboccipital window. Peak systolic velocity (PSV), mean velocity (MV), end diastolic velocity (EDV), resistance index (RI), and pulsatility index (PI) were measured for each vessel. Blood pressure (BP) and heart rate (HR) were also recorded before and after sedation in both groups. Statistically significant differences were found for PSV, MV and EDV when RMCA and LMCA were interrogated before and after sedation. PSV, RI and PI were found to be statistically significantly different when the study was performed on the BA. These results should be taken in account when a transcranial Doppler is performed in dogs sedated with the mentioned protocols and it might suggest some degree of neuroprotection.

Clinical variables and neuromonitoring information (intracranial pressure and brain tissue oxygenation) as predictors of brain-death development after severe traumatic brain injury.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to ascertain the role of clinical variables and neuromonitoring data as predictors of brain death (BD) after severe traumatic brain injury (TBI). PATIENTS AND METHODS: This prospective observational study involved severe TBI patients admitted to the intensive care unit between October 2009 and May 2011. The following variables were recorded: gender, age, reference Glasgow Coma Scale after resuscitation, pupillary reactivity, prehospital hypotension and desaturation, injury severity score, computed tomography (CT) findings, intracranial hypertension, and low brain tissue oxygenation (Pti02) levels (<16 mm Hg), as well as the final result of BD. RESULTS: Among 61 patients (86.9% males) who met the inclusion criteria, the average age was 37.69 ± 16.44 years. Traffic accidents were the main cause of TBI (62.3%). The patients at risk of progressing to BD (14.8% of the entire cohort) were those with a mass lesion on CT (odds ratio [OR] 33.6; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 3.75-300.30; P = .002), altered pupillary reaction at admission (OR 25.5; 95% CI: 2.27-285.65; P = .009), as well low Pti02 levels on admission (OR 20.41; 95% CI: 3.52-118.33; P < .001) and during the first 24 hours of neuromonitoring (OR 20; 95% CI: 2.90-137.83; P < .001). Multivariate logistic regression showed that a low Pti02 level on admission was the best independent predictor for BD (OR 20.41; 95% CI: 3.53-118.33; P = .001). CONCLUSIONS: Clinical variables and neuromonitoring information may identify TBI patients at risk of deterioration to BD.

Accuracy of the S100ß protein as a marker of brain damage in traumatic brain injury.

INTRODUCTION: This study tested the hypothesis that S100ß is a useful screening tool for detecting intracranial lesion (IL) in patients with a normal level of consciousness after traumatic brain injury (TBI). METHODS: One hundred and forty-three post-TBI patients without a decrease in consciousness (GCS = 15) and with at least one neurological symptom (e.g. transitory loss of consciousness, amnesia, headache, dizziness or vomiting) were prospectively included. A blood sample was drawn at 6-hours post-TBI. A routine CT scan was obtained within 24 hours post-injury. Diagnostic properties of S100ß for IL prediction in CT scan findings were tested using ROC-analysis. RESULTS: A total of 15 patients (10.5%) had IL. Serum levels were significantly higher in these patients. Significant differences were found between S100ß levels and CT scan findings (p = 0.007). ROC-analysis showed that S100ß is a useful tool for detecting the presence of IL in CT scans (p = 0.007). In this series, the best cut-off for S100ß is 0.130 µg L(-1), with 100% sensitivity and 32.81% specificity. CONCLUSION: Within the first 6 hours post-TBI, serum S100ß seems to be an effective biochemical indicator of IL in patients without a decrease in consciousness. These results indicate that higher S100ß cut-off values substantially improve the clinical relevance of this protein.

Effect of transient carotid artery compression during transcranial Doppler ultrasonography in dogs.

Changes in blood flow in the arteries of the canine skull base following compression of the ipsilateral carotid artery were evaluated. Forty healthy conscious dogs were evaluated during examination in lateral recumbency. Using the temporal window, the rostral, middle and caudal cerebral arteries were evaluated. The basilar artery was studied through the suboccipital window. Following compression, the pulse Doppler signal was reduced or inverted when interrogating the rostral or middle cerebral artery, and no change was observed when the caudal cerebral artery or basilar artery was evaluated.

Muerte encefálica: repercusión sobre órganos y tejidos / Brain death: Repercussion on the organs and tissues

La muerte encefálica se acompaña de una serie de efectos sistémicos, hemodinámicos, hormonales e inflamatorios que tienen una repercusión relevante en los órganos y los tejidos de la economía. Cada vez hay más evidencias de que los órganos provenientes de donantes fallecidos en muerte encefálica presentan un grado de respuesta inflamatoria secundaria al daño encefálico y, en ocasiones, proporcional a la intensidad y a la velocidad de progresión de éste. Tanto estudios clínicos como estudios experimentales han mostrado que el resultado de los órganos de donantes fallecidos en parada cardíaca o donantes vivos tienen iguales o mejores resultados clínicos que los obtenidos en donantes en muerte encefálica que han presentado el proceso inflamatorio secundario a ésta. Hay pruebas de que esta respuesta inflamatoria acontece en el pulmón, el corazón, los riñones, el hígado y el intestino, e igualmente se incrementan también las pruebas de que el grado de respuesta inflamatoria observada en los órganos tiene una influencia importante en el resultado final del trasplante. En consecuencia, el desarrollo del conocimiento de las vías que interrelacionan el daño encefálico con la respuesta orgánica inflamatoria abre una importante área de conocimiento y posibilita que futuras estrategias terapéuticas encaminadas a modular la respuesta sistémica al daño encefálico permitan mejorar la calidad de los órganos obtenidos para trasplante, así como incrementar la supervivencia del injerto y de los receptores de trasplantes de órganos sólidos (AU)

Brain death is accompanied by a series of hemodynamic, hormonal and inflammatory systemic effects that have an important repercussion on the economy of the organs and tissues. There is increasing evidence that the organs from brain death donors have an inflammatory response grade secondary to brain death and sometimes proportional to the intensity and rate of its progression. Both clinical and experimental studies have shown that the result of organs from heart arrest deceased donors or live donors have the same or better clinical results than those obtained in brain death donors and who have suffered the inflammatory process secondary to it. There is proof that this inflammatory response occurs in the lung, heart, kidneys, liver, intestine. Furthermore, the evidence also shows that the grade of inflammatory response observed in the organs has an important influence on the final outcome of the transplant. Consequently, the development of the knowledge regarding the pathways that interrelate brain death with the inflammatory organ response provides us with an important area of knowledge, which allow for future therapeutic strategies aimed at modulating the systemic response to brain death to improve the quality of the organs obtained for transplant and also to increase graft survival of the solid organ transplant recipients (AU)

[Brain death: repercussion on the organs and tissues]. / Muerte encefálica: repercusión sobre órganos y tejidos.

Brain death is accompanied by a series of hemodynamic, hormonal and inflammatory systemic effects that have an important repercussion on the economy of the organs and tissues. There is increasing evidence that the organs from brain death donors have an inflammatory response grade secondary to brain death and sometimes proportional to the intensity and rate of its progression. Both clinical and experimental studies have shown that the result of organs from heart arrest deceased donors or live donors have the same or better clinical results than those obtained in brain death donors and who have suffered the inflammatory process secondary to it. There is proof that this inflammatory response occurs in the lung, heart, kidneys, liver, intestine. Furthermore, the evidence also shows that the grade of inflammatory response observed in the organs has an important influence on the final outcome of the transplant. Consequently, the development of the knowledge regarding the pathways that interrelate brain death with the inflammatory organ response provides us with an important area of knowledge, which allow for future therapeutic strategies aimed at modulating the systemic response to brain death to improve the quality of the organs obtained for transplant and also to increase graft survival of the solid organ transplant recipients.

Monitorización de la presión tisular de oxígeno (PtiO2) en la hipoxia cerebral: aproximación diagnóstica y terapéutica / Monitoring of tissue oxygen pressure (PtiO2) in cerebral hypoxia: diagnostic and therapeutic approach

Una de las causas principales de lesión cerebral secundaria es la hipoxia cerebral, fundamentalmente de origen isquémico. No obstante, la oxigenación tisular cerebral depende de múltiples variables fisiológicas y la hipoxia cerebral puede ser originada por una alteración de cualquiera de ellas. Aunque han sido desarrollados varios métodos de monitorización continua de la oxigenación cerebral en pacientes neurocríticos, la medición directa y continua de la presión de oxígeno en el tejido cerebral (PtiO2) es una realidad en el manejo de pacientes neurocríticos desde los últimos años. Esta técnica destaca por su fiabilidad y valor de la información que proporciona. En el presente artículo se expone una revisión de los aspectos más relevantes de la monitorización de la PtiO2 y se propone un protocolo para su interpretación. Este algoritmo pretende facilitar la identificación de diferentes tipos de hipoxia cerebral y la correcta elección terapéutica en el complejo proceso de toma de decisiones en pacientes neurológicos críticos en riesgo de hipoxia cerebral

One of the main causes of secondary cerebral injury is cerebral hypoxia, basically of ischemic origin. However, cerebral tissue oxygenation depends on multiple physiological variables and cerebral hypoxia may be caused by an alteration of any one of them. Although several methods of continuous cerebral oxygenation monitoring of neurocritical patients have been developed, direct and continuous measurement of the oxygen pressure in the cerebral tissue (PtiO2) has been a reality in the handling of the neurocritical patients over recent years. This technique is highlighted by its reliability and value of the information that it provides. This present article presents a review of the most outstanding aspects of the PtiO2 monitoring and proposes a protocol for the interpretation of this monitoring technique. This algorithm attempts to facilitate the identification of the different types of different cerebral hypoxia and of the correct therapeutic choice in the complex decision making process in neurocritical patients at risk of cerebral hypoxia

[Monitoring of tissue oxygen pressure (PtiO2) in cerebral hypoxia: diagnostic and therapeutic approach]. / Monitorización de la presión tisular de oxígeno (PtiO2) en la hipoxia cerebral: aproximación diagnóstica y terapéutica.

One of the main causes of secondary cerebral injury is cerebral hypoxia, basically of ischemic origin. However, cerebral tissue oxygenation depends on multiple physiological variables and cerebral hypoxia may be caused by an alteration of any one of them. Although several methods of continuous cerebral oxygenation monitoring of neurocritical patients have been developed, direct and continuous measurement of the oxygen pressure in the cerebral tissue (PtiO2) has been a reality in the handling of the neurocritical patients over recent years. This technique is highlighted by its reliability and value of the information that it provides. This present article presents a review of the most outstanding aspects of the PtiO2 monitoring and proposes a protocol for the interpretation of this monitoring technique. This algorithm attempts to facilitate the identification of the different types of different cerebral hypoxia and of the correct therapeutic choice in the complex decision making process in neurocritical patients at risk of cerebral hypoxia.

Electrolytic disorders, hyperosmolar states, and lactic acidosis in brain-dead patients.

Despite the use of well-accepted protocols for donor maintenance, the severe electrolytic disorders are not infrequent with deleterious consequences to the organs. The objective of our survey was to determine the incidence of episodes of electrolyte disorders among brain-dead patients (despite of rigid protocols of maintenance) and the rate of anaerobic metabolism in these patients (suggestive of an occult systemic hypoperfusion). The study group of 50 brain-dead patients underwent therapy to maintain normal arterial pressure, urine output, and body temperature. Standard monitoring for brain-dead patients was followed, except for a frequent evaluation of electrolytes, including glucose, sodium, potassium, phosphorus, osmolality, base excess, and lactate plasma levels. Our results demonstrate that with frequent determinations of electrolytes, despite following strict protocols of maintenance, there was a high incidence of hyperglycemia, hypophosphotemia, hypokaemia, and hyperosmolality. Interesting findings were the high incidence of elevated lactate, and the relationship between lactate levels and bases deficit as well as hypernatremia. It can be concluded that, even following rigid protocols, the maintenance of brain-dead patients demands a close evaluation of electrolyte levels. Our results also suggest that the inclusion in the monitoring protocol of anerobic metabolism data including lactate levels can help to avoid occult ischemia of organs, and consequently improve their quality for transplantation.

Brain death after severe traumatic brain injury: the role of systemic secondary brain insults.

Secondary brain insults predominantly due to hypotension are frequent among patients with fatal traumatic brain injury. We assessed the correlation between different systemic secondary brain insults and brain death in 404 patients admitted to our intensive care unit (ICU) after severe traumatic brain injury. We collated data on hypoxemia and hypotension prior to as well as the occurrence of hypoxemia, hypotension, shock, anemia, hyperglycemia, and hyperthermia within the first 24 hours after ICU admission. We also considered both the presence of extracranial injuries and the category of traumatic brain injury using computerized tomography. The 59 patients (14.6%) who developed brain death, were significantly older than patients without a fatal neurological outcome (46.1 +/- 22 vs 29.5 +/- 14.9 years; P < .0001). Intracranial mass lesions, whether surgically evacuated were more frequent among brain-dead patients. The systemic secondary brain insults significantly associated with brain death were hypoxemia, hypotension, shock, anemia, and hyperglycemia within the first 24 hours after ICU admission. After multivariate analysis, the factors that independently predicted brain death were the occurrence of shock (odds ratio [OR], 6.74; 95% confidence interval [CI], 2.85-15.84; P = .001) and older age (OR, 1.05; 95% CI, 1.03-1.07; P = .003). In conclusion, early shock seems to be the major systemic secondary brain insult associated with brain death in patients with severe traumatic brain injury. Prevention of or correction of shock might help to either decrease the occurrence of a fatal neurological outcome or in brain-dead patients to preserve organs in better condition for procurement.

Identification by CT scan of ischemic stroke patients with high risk of brain death.

The identification of patients with high risk of evolution to brain death is one of the more important tasks of transplant coordination teams. Although most of pool of potential donors come from the group of patients who suffer a head injury or hemorrhagic stroke, the procurement of organs from brain-dead patients suffering an ischemic stroke as the cause of brain damage must also be considered. The main objective of this study was to investigate the radiological signs that in the CT scan of admission to a neurological ICU are more frequently associated with progression to brain death. We studied the CT scans of 15 brain-dead patients after an ischemic stroke versus the scans of 15 recovered patients admitted to ICU with the same diagnosis. The radiological signs included: insular ribbon sign, hyperintensities inside the big arteries of the base of the skull, hemispheric hypodensities, midline shift, and compression of the cerebrospinal fluid spaces. There were two signs significantly associated with brain death: midline shifts and the compression of the ambiens cistern. It may be concluded that analysis of the CT scan at admission of patients with an ischemic stroke in the ICU can predict the risk of evolution to brain death.

Medicina de cuidados intensivos / Intensive care medicine

No disponible

Diagnosis of brain death by transcranial Doppler sonography: solutions for cases of difficult sonic windows.

Delays in diagnosis of brain death have definite consequences for the organ retrieval and transplantation process. It is advisable to use accurate diagnostic methods. Transcranial Doppler sonography is a well-accepted technique for diagnosing cerebral circulatory arrest. However, in some cases, the access to the intracranial circulation via the temporal window is difficult. In 43 brain-dead patients we evaluated the rate of impossibility of insonation of middle cerebral artery using a temporal window and the usefulness of an orbital window for insonation of the carotid siphon. In 39 patients the usual protocol of insonation (temporal window and foramen magnum window) was sufficient to demonstrate cerebral circulatory arrest. In 10 patients, including all the cases in which it was impossible to use a temporal approach, the carotid siphon was successfully insonated, showing in all the cases the existence of a sonographic pattern compatible with cerebral circulatory arrest. It may be concluded that the use of an orbital window for exploring intracranial circulation by transcranial Doppler sonography can be a useful tool in cases of difficult sonic windows.

Brain death due to supratentorial masses: diagnosis using transcranial Doppler sonography.

Since cadaveric donation is the main source of organs for transplantation in many countries, the diagnosis of brain death is an important issue. The cessation of cerebral circulation is one phenomenon closely related to brain death. Transcranial Doppler sonography is one of the accepted techniques to establish cessation of cerebral circulation. One of the limitations attributed to Doppler is the lack of sensitivity for this diagnosis. The objective of this research was to establish whether transcranial Doppler sonography showed acceptable sensitivity and whether this was affected by the location of the intracranial mass effect. Twenty-four patients underwent transcranial Doppler sonography to establish the incidence of the three sonographic patterns associated with brain death: separation diastole-systole, reverberating flow, and systolic spikes. In all the cases the insonation of the arteries of the base of the skull was performed. In supratentorial lesions, the predominant pattern was a reverberating flow, while in infratentorial lesions systolic spikes pattern was most frequent. Our study showed a high sensitivity of transcranial Doppler sonography for the diagnosis of brain death and the existence of different mechanisms of cerebral circulatory arrest depending on the location of the intracranial pressure wedge.